
Build the Base: Why Clubs Should Stop Chasing the Next Star
Every club has at least one ten-year-old who wins the under-10s, hits it cleaner than the rest, and suddenly has a coach, two parents and half the club convinced they are looking at a future Wimbledon champion.
I have been coaching since 1994 and have seen that story play out so many times, even believing it myself in my younger coaching days. I can tell you however it usually ends with a burnt-out fifteen-year-old who no longer wants to pick up a racket having been pushed too much by all including the parents, and a club that spent its court time, best coaches and hours on one child while dozens of others quietly drifted away.
It is time we got our priorities straight and fill clubs with base players. The stars from whatever path and environment they come from will look after themselves over time.
Nobody can pick a champion at ten
Let us be honest about what we are actually seeing in a ten-year-old. We are seeing a child who is perhaps a little older in their school year, a little bigger, a little more coordinated earlier than their friends, and probably playing more hours with parents who could afford coaching more than once a week. I have seen a great junior have 5 lessons a week and stood out from others due to this but fell short of making it as a player. But lets not forget tennis brings more to a persons life than just thinking they will be a top notch player.
The research backs this up. It is called the relative age effect, and junior tennis is full of it. A study of 2,697 boys in Chinese junior tennis found that around 60% of U14 and U16 players were born in the first half of the year, and more than a third in the first three months alone. The same pattern shows up among girls and at the World Junior Tennis Finals. Being born in January is not talent it is merely a head start.
The player who dominates at ten is very often overtaken at fourteen by the kid who was smaller, slower to develop and simply kept turning up, and I can guarantee that this is the player who stays at the club for the remainder of their life.
Even the very best juniors are a poor bet. Researchers tracked the winners of three of the biggest U14 events in the world, including Les Petits As. Of the boys who won, 57% never made the ATP top 200, and fewer than half of the winners made the top 100. A second study followed 1,527 players who reached the top 50 of Europe's U14 or U16 rankings. Roughly 30% made the pro top 200. Just 4% made the top 10.
Remember, those are the best juniors on the continent. If they mostly do not make it, the odds for the best ten-year-old at your club are far longer.
If we cannot reliably predict who will make it, why are we building entire programmes around guessing?
The hidden cost of chasing the one
When a club pours its energy into a handful of "elite" juniors, something has to give. Usually it is everyone else, I saw this at another club I worked out abroad, all eyes on one player and I could tell early on he had competitive issues.
- The best court times go to the squad in a smaller club.
- The best coaches work with the few, so the many get whoever is left.
- The message to every other child is clear: you are not one of the special ones and believe me I hear this from a club not too far from me currently.
And children hear that message loud and clear, so they leave along with their parents to go elsewhere. Their friends never join so the club shrinks, the competition inside the club gets thinner, and ironically the elite players end up with fewer people to hit with and fewer matches to play.
Then there is the pressure on the child at the top. Ten-year-olds being told they are the next big thing, parents investing thousands, results analysed after every tournament. That is a heavy bag for a small person to carry.
The medical research is clear on this too. A study of 519 US junior tennis players found 70% had already specialised in tennis, at an average age of just 10.4. Sports medicine reviews link early specialisation to higher rates of overuse injury, psychological stress and quitting young. One study found that children who did more hours of organised sport a week than their age in years had a higher risk of serious overuse injury. A ten-year-old doing twelve hours a week is in that zone.
What a strong base actually gives you
A club full of base players is not a club that has given up on excellence. It is the only kind of club where excellence has a real chance of growing.
Numbers create competition. Forty juniors in a programme produce better match play, better rivalries and better motivation than six.
Numbers create a pathway. Players move up at their own pace, and there is always someone a step ahead to chase and someone a step behind to help.
Numbers keep the club alive. Juniors become adult members. Adult members become volunteers, team captains, committee members and parents who bring the next generation through the gate.
Numbers protect late developers. When you keep everyone in the game, you keep the eleven-year-old who will suddenly click at fifteen. Cut them loose early and you never find out what they could have been.
The top of the pyramid is only as tall as the base is wide. Narrow the base and the top comes down with it.
Fun first, then skill, then performance
I am not saying high standards do not matter. They do. But the order matters more.
Children stay in tennis because they enjoy it, because their friends are there, and because they can feel themselves getting better. Get those three things right and you will have a club full of players who want to train harder, compete more and stay for life. Some of them will turn out to be very good indeed.
Ask the children and they will tell you the same thing. A 2024 Ohio State study found the number one reason people gave for dropping out of youth sport was that it was not fun, cited by 45%. Next came feeling they were not good enough, at 31%. When researchers at George Washington University asked young players what made sport fun, winning came 48th out of 81 factors.
Get the order wrong, by putting results and rankings first at ten years old, and you lose the enjoyment that keeps them coming back.
What clubs and coaches can do tomorrow
- Measure success by retention, not trophies. How many juniors did you have last year, and how many are still playing this year?
- Give every group your best coaching. The beginner group deserves a well-planned, engaging session just as much as the squad.
- Run a clear, staged pathway. Children should know where they are, what comes next and how to get there, whatever their level.
- Fill the courts with match play. Internal leagues, team events and fun competitions for everyone, not just the selected few.
- Talk to parents early. Help them see the long game. A happy, improving twelve-year-old is worth far more than an anxious, burnt-out one with a trophy.
- Keep the door open. Let late starters in. Let players drop down and move back up. Never tell a child they have missed the boat.
The bottom line
The next great player from your club is almost certainly not the one everybody is talking about at ten. It might be the quiet kid in the Tuesday group. It might be a child who has not even joined yet.
The only way to make sure you do not miss them is to build a club where everyone is welcome, everyone is coached well and everyone wants to stay.
Fill the courts. Build the base. The stars will come.
Sources
- Brouwers, De Bosscher et al., The relationship between performances at U-14 international youth tournaments and later success in tennis
- Grove & Jetter (2014), The superstar quest: does youth talent predict professional success for female and male tennis players?
- Aku & Yang (2023), The relative age effect among Chinese junior men's tennis players, PLOS ONE
- Jayanthi et al. (2013), Sports specialization in young athletes: evidence-based recommendations, Sports Health
- Myer et al. (2015), Sport specialization, part I: does early sports specialization increase negative outcomes?, Sports Health
- Upenieks, Ryan & Knoester (2024), Playing youth sports linked to better mental health in adults, Ohio State University
- Visek et al. (2014), The fun integration theory, George Washington University, as reported by MHSAA
Andy Dowsett is the founder of SYSTEM-9 Tennis and has been coaching since 1994. The SYSTEM-9 pathway gives clubs a staged, ready-to-run programme designed to keep every player progressing, from their first Red Ball session to competitive match play.